# Public vs Private College: Which Pays for Itself Faster? What Earnings Data Shows > Public colleges pay for themselves faster than private colleges. According to CollegesRef data, public institutions require a median of 0.97 years of graduate earnings to cover a four-year degree, while private nonprofits require 1.55 years... - Page: https://www.collegesref.com/blog/public-vs-private-college-which-pays-for-itself-faster-what-earnings-data-shows - Category: College Guides - Author: CollegesRef Editorial - Published: 2026-11-22 Public colleges pay for themselves faster than private colleges. According to CollegesRef data from the College Scorecard, public institutions require a median of 0.97 years of graduate earnings to cover a four-year degree, while private nonprofit colleges require 1.55 years. This difference matters most for families who must borrow to cover the gap between financial aid and the total cost of attendance. A common misunderstanding is that a higher sticker price at a private college always translates to a longer payback period. In reality, generous institutional grants can lower the net price for low-income students, sometimes making a private nonprofit college cheaper than an out-of-state public option. Families should look past published tuition rates and focus on the average net price, which represents the actual amount students pay after subtracting grants and scholarships. ## Key takeaways - Public colleges pay for themselves in a median of 0.97 years of graduate earnings compared to 1.55 years for private nonprofit colleges. - The national median net price after grants at four-year colleges is $19,835, which families must compare against projected graduate earnings. - Private nonprofit colleges have a higher median net price of $27,122 but yield higher median graduate earnings of $69,642 after ten years. - Private for-profit colleges carry high financial risks, with a median net price of $27,612 and low median graduate earnings of $45,510. - Dependent undergraduate students face strict federal borrowing limits, allowing them to borrow a maximum of $27,000 over four years of college. ## Comparing Public vs Private College Cost and Earnings ### The Net Price Difference A student comparing higher education sectors must look past published sticker prices to find the actual net price, which represents the total cost of tuition, fees, books, and living expenses minus all grants and scholarships. According to the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition, the national median net price across 1,557 reporting four-year colleges is $19,835. However, this average masks a massive divide between public and private institutions. As shown in the table below, public colleges offer a median average net price of $10,516, driven by state subsidies and lower in-state tuition rates. In contrast, private nonprofit colleges carry a median average net price of $27,122, even though their median sticker tuition is $48,600. This gap of more than $16,600 per year means a family must identify how much institutional aid the student will actually receive. To find your true cost, you must request a financial aid award letter from each college and locate the "net price" or "remaining cost" line, rather than relying on the published tuition. Many states also offer programs to reduce these costs further, which you can explore in our guide on [State Merit Scholarships That Reward Staying In-State](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/state-merit-scholarships-that-reward-staying-in-state). To estimate these multi-year expenses quickly, you can use the [CollegesRef College Cost Estimator](https://www.collegesref.com/tools/cost-estimator), which calculates a four-year cost estimate using a college's published tuition and average net price alongside median graduate earnings. The tool provides a baseline for comparison but does not guarantee individual financial aid packages. ### The Graduate Earnings Gap Ten years after entering college, graduates from different sectors experience significantly different financial outcomes. CollegesRef data compiled from the federal College Scorecard shows that former students from private nonprofit colleges earn a median salary of $69,642. This is over $20,000 higher than the median earnings of public college graduates, who earn $49,519 ten years after enrollment. This earnings premium is closely tied to graduation rates. Private nonprofit institutions achieve a median graduation rate of 70%, whereas public institutions sit at 42%. Students who complete their degrees are far more likely to secure high-paying professional roles. For example, Texas A & M University-College Station, a large public institution, reaches an 85% graduation rate, demonstrating that select public universities perform well above the sectoral median. Conversely, private for-profit colleges present the most challenging financial equation. These institutions have a median net price of $27,612, yet their median graduate earnings ten years after entry are just $45,510, which is lower than the median for public colleges. Combined with a low median graduation rate of 42%, the for-profit sector often leaves students with substantial debt and limited earning power to pay it back. When evaluating any college, ask the admissions office for their specific College Scorecard program-level earnings data to see if your intended major justifies the net price. | Sector | Colleges | Median net price | Median in-state tuition | Median out-of-state tuition | Median graduation rate | Median earnings (10 yrs) | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | Public | 1,054 | $10,516 | $6,089 | $12,656 | 42% | $49,519 | | Private nonprofit | 326 | $27,122 | $48,600 | $48,600 | 70% | $69,642 | | Private for-profit | 62 | $27,612 | $17,370 | $17,370 | 42% | $45,510 | *Source: CollegesRef analysis of [IPEDS](https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/) and [College Scorecard](https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/) data for 1,442 published U.S. colleges with at least 2,000 students (latest data year 2025). Net price is the average paid by first-time, full-time students who receive grant aid.* ## How Long to Pay Off College Degree by Sector ### The Degree Payback Metric Explained To evaluate the financial return of a higher education credential, families can use the degree payback metric. This calculation divides the total net cost of a four-year degree by the median annual earnings of graduates ten years after they first enrolled. It measures how many years of post-college salary it would take to cover the out-of-pocket cost of the education. According to CollegesRef data, the national median net price after grants at four-year colleges is $19,835. At the median of 1,355 four-year public and private nonprofit colleges, four years at the average net price cost 1.31 years of former students' median earnings ten years after they enrolled, which translates to $19,916 a year against $59,737 in earnings, according to the CollegesRef degree payback database. This metric assumes a student graduates in four years and pays the average net price reported on the federal financial aid database. To find your own projected net price, you must look at your financial aid award letter, locate the "Net Cost" or "Remaining Cost" line, and multiply that figure by four. You can compare these timelines across regions by viewing the [degree payback by state](https://www.collegesref.com/data/degree-payback-by-state) database. For shorter vocational pathways, families can also compare a [Community College or Trade School? Two-Year and Certificate Programs Side by Side](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/community-college-or-trade-school-two-year-and-certificate-programs-side-by-side) to see how shorter enrollment periods alter the payback timeline. ### Public College Payback Timelines Public higher education institutions offer the fastest route to clearing the cost of a degree. CollegesRef data from the College Scorecard shows that public colleges require a median payback period of 0.97 years of graduate earnings. This rapid recovery of costs is driven by low in-state pricing. Public colleges carry a median average net price of $10,516 per year, alongside a median in-state tuition of $6,089. Ten years after enrolling, former students at these institutions earn a median salary of $49,519. Because the total four-year net cost at a typical public university remains low, a graduate earning the median salary can cover their entire net tuition, fees, room, and board with less than one year of gross income. This low barrier to entry makes public universities highly resilient financial choices, even though their median graduation rate sits at 42%. ### Private College Payback Timelines Private nonprofit colleges present a different financial equation, characterized by higher upfront costs offset by higher median earnings. At these institutions, the median payback period rises to 1.55 years of graduate earnings. The median average net price at private nonprofit colleges is $27,122 per year, which is more than double the public college median. However, graduates from private nonprofit institutions secure a median salary of $69,642 ten years after entry. While the earnings are higher than those of public college graduates, the steep net price extends the time required to pay off the degree. Families evaluating a private nonprofit option should contact the college financial aid office to request a copy of their historical net price by income bracket to see if their actual cost will align with this median. ## When Is Private College Worth It Over a Public Option? ### The Impact of Graduation Rates on Real Cost A low sticker price at a public university only saves money if the student actually finishes the degree. CollegesRef data from the College Scorecard shows a stark completion gap between sectors: the median graduation rate is 42% at public colleges compared to 70% at private nonprofit institutions. When a student takes five or six years to graduate from a public university, they pay for extra semesters of tuition, fees, and housing. They also lose a year or two of professional salary. A private nonprofit college with smaller classes and structured advising often helps students graduate in exactly four years. Families comparing options should read our analysis of [Small Colleges vs Large Universities: Class Size, Support, and Fit](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/small-colleges-vs-large-universities-class-size-support-and-fit) to understand how these structural differences affect completion. To evaluate this risk, request the four-year graduation rate specifically for your intended major from each college's admissions office. If a public university has a low four-year completion rate in your field, the real cost of attendance may quickly surpass that of a private alternative. ### Generous Institutional Grants for Lower Income Brackets Private nonprofit colleges have a median average net price of $27,122, which is significantly higher than the public college median of $10,516. However, wealthy private institutions often use their endowments to discount tuition heavily for low- and middle-income families. A student with a lower family income might receive an institutional financial aid package that brings their actual net price below the cost of an in-state public university. To find these opportunities, families must look past the sticker price and locate the "Net Price Calculator" on each college's financial aid website. Input your family's latest tax figures into these calculators before applying. Compare the estimated net price on the output screen to the national median net price of $19,835. If a private college offers a net price well below this national median, it may yield a faster payback period than your local state school. ### High-Paying Majors and Pre-Professional Tracks The financial return of any degree depends heavily on the graduate's career path. While public colleges pay back their costs faster on average, certain high-paying majors justify the higher net price of a private nonprofit institution. According to College Scorecard data, former students of private nonprofit colleges earn a median of $69,642 ten years after entry, compared to $49,519 for public college graduates. This earnings premium is often driven by strong pre-professional tracks, robust alumni networks, and specialized majors in fields like engineering, finance, or nursing. To see how these earnings affect long-term value, read our guide on how [college ROI explained](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/college-roi-how-long-until-a-degree-pays-for-itself) the relationship between net price and starting salaries. Before committing to a private college, ask the department chair for the median salary of their graduates three years after graduation. If the department's graduates earn significantly more than the median public university graduate in the same field, the private degree remains the stronger financial choice. ## The Hidden Risks of Private For-Profit Colleges While public and private nonprofit institutions present distinct paths to graduation, private for-profit colleges operate under a business model that frequently results in high debt and low completion rates. Families evaluating these institutions must look closely at federal disclosures before signing an enrollment agreement. ### High Net Prices and Low Graduation Rates For-profit colleges often market themselves as affordable, flexible alternatives to traditional universities. However, CollegesRef data shows that the median average net price at private for-profit colleges is $27,612 per year. This is nearly identical to the private nonprofit median of $27,122, and more than double the public college median of $10,516. At the same time, the likelihood of actually earning a degree at a for-profit school is significantly lower. The median graduation rate for private for-profit colleges is just 42%, matching the public college median but falling far behind the 70% median graduation rate of private nonprofit institutions. Looking at specific institutions reveals even steeper risks. According to College Scorecard data, University of Phoenix-Arizona has a graduation rate of just 21%. Southern New Hampshire University, a large private nonprofit with a heavy online presence, graduates 42% of its students. Grand Canyon University, which operates as a proprietary institution, has a 54% graduation rate. When a student enrolls in a program with a low graduation rate, they face a high probability of leaving with student loans but no degree to help pay them back. ### Earnings Outcomes for For-Profit Graduates The financial risk of the for-profit sector compounds after leaving school, as graduate earnings rarely justify the high initial net price. CollegesRef data shows that the median earnings ten years after entry for graduates of private for-profit colleges is $45,510. This is the lowest of any sector, falling below the public college median of $49,519 and far below the private nonprofit median of $69,642. High costs combined with low earnings create a prolonged payback period. To avoid this trap, applicants should request the College Scorecard data directly from the admissions office or search the official database themselves. Before committing, you can [compare two colleges side by side](https://www.collegesref.com/compare) to see how a specific for-profit option stacks up against a local public university. When evaluating a for-profit program, ask the financial aid office for the exact percentage of students who borrow federal loans and the median debt of graduates in your specific major. If the office cannot or will not provide these figures on paper, treat it as a major red flag. You can also consult the CollegesRef guide on [Best Value Colleges: Graduate Earnings vs. Net Price (2026)](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/best-value-colleges-earnings-vs-net-price) to find institutions that offer a more secure return on your educational investment. ## Federal Student Loan Limits and Financing the Payback Gap When the net price of a college exceeds what a family can pay out of pocket, federal student loans are often the first financing tool families consider. However, federal lending programs do not offer unlimited funding. The U.S. Department of Education caps the amount of money a student can borrow directly, which often leaves a substantial funding gap at higher-cost private institutions. Families must understand these strict limits before signing a financial aid award letter. ### Direct Loan Limits for Dependent and Independent Students For dependent undergraduate students, the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program limits borrowing by academic year. According to [studentaid.gov](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized), a dependent student can borrow a maximum of $5,500 in their first year, with no more than $3,500 in subsidized loans. This limit rises to $6,500 in the second year and $7,500 in the third year and beyond. Over a four-year undergraduate career, a dependent student can borrow at most $27,000. The absolute aggregate limit for dependent undergraduates is $31,000, of which no more than $23,000 may be subsidized. Independent undergraduate students, who do not have access to parental financial support, have higher annual borrowing limits to help cover their costs. These students can borrow up to $9,500 in their first year, $10,500 in their second year, and $12,500 in their third year and beyond. The aggregate limit for independent undergraduates is $57,500. This total far exceeds the $27,000 maximum federal loan limit for a dependent student. Families must compare their [graduate debt vs earnings](https://www.collegesref.com/data/graduate-debt-vs-earnings-by-state) to ensure that any additional private loans used to bridge this gap do not lead to unmanageable monthly payments after graduation. ### Parent PLUS and Grad PLUS Borrowing Caps To cover the remaining funding gap, parents of dependent undergraduate students often turn to Parent PLUS loans. For loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2026, Parent PLUS borrowing is capped at $20,000 per year and $65,000 in total per dependent student, according to [studentaid.gov](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/plus/parent). This cap prevents families from taking on six-figure federal parental debt, which was previously a common path for funding high-cost private universities. For students planning to pursue advanced degrees, the federal borrowing landscape has also changed. For new borrowers from July 1, 2026, Grad PLUS loans end. Graduate students may now borrow up to $20,500 a year, with a $100,000 aggregate limit, in Direct Unsubsidized Loans. Professional students, such as those in medical or law programs, may borrow up to $50,000 a year, with a $200,000 aggregate limit, according to [studentaid.gov](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized). To act on these limits, families should look at Line 1 of their financial aid award letter to identify the exact mix of subsidized and unsubsidized Direct Loans offered. If the net price minus these federal loans leaves a gap, parents should contact the college financial aid office to request a formal "Special Circumstances Appeal" form if their financial situation has changed since filing the FAFSA. This step is especially critical when evaluating institutions featured on the list of [Colleges With the Highest Graduate Earnings: Top 25 Ranked (2026–27)](https://www.collegesref.com/blog/colleges-with-the-highest-graduate-earnings), where high starting salaries may tempt families to over-borrow through private alternative loans. ## How to Calculate Your Own College Payback Period Comparing financial aid offers requires looking beyond the sticker price. By calculating a customized payback period, families can see exactly how many years of post-graduation salary it will take to cover the net cost of a degree. This calculation relies on real financial aid offers and federal outcome data rather than marketing brochures. ### Step 1: Find Your Net Price Estimate Do not rely on the published tuition figure on a college website. Instead, locate the net price, which is the actual cost a family pays after subtracting federal, state, and institutional grants or scholarships. To find this number for a specific student, gather the official financial aid award letters sent by each college's financial aid office. Look for the line labeled "Net Cost," "Net Price," or "Estimated Balance Due" after all gift aid is applied. If you are early in the planning process and do not have an official aid letter, use the [CollegesRef College Cost Estimator](https://www.collegesref.com/tools/cost-estimator) to generate a four-year cost estimate based on historical net price data for your income bracket. You can also search the [colleges by state map](https://www.collegesref.com/state) to find local institutions and access their individual net price calculators, which every federally funded college is required to host on its website. Multiply this annual net price by four to determine the total estimated cost of the degree. ### Step 2: Locate Median Graduate Earnings Once you have the total cost, you need a realistic projection of what graduates from that institution earn. Do not use the national average salary or the school's self-reported alumni survey, which often suffers from low response rates. Instead, search the official College Scorecard database at https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data/ for each college on your list. Look for the "Median Earnings" metric, which shows the earnings of former students ten years after they first enrolled in the institution. This figure is pulled directly from federal administrative records, making it the most reliable baseline for your calculations. If you already know your intended major, look up the field-specific median earnings on the same platform, as a computer science graduate and an education graduate from the same university will face very different payback timelines. ### Step 3: Run the Payback Equation With both figures in hand, you can calculate the payback metric used in the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition. Divide the total four-year net price by the median annual earnings. $$\text{Payback Period (Years)} = \frac{\text{Annual Net Price} \times 4}{\text{Median Graduate Earnings}}$$ For example, if a public university has an annual net price of $11,000, the total four-year cost is $44,000. If the median graduate earnings ten years after entry are $50,000, divide $44,000 by $50,000 to get a payback period of 0.88 years. If a private nonprofit college offers a net price of $25,000 per year ($100,000 total) and its graduates earn a median salary of $70,000, the payback period is 1.43 years. This simple ratio allows you to compare different sectors directly and determine which school offers the fastest return on your investment. For more detailed analysis of institutional value, consult our comprehensive [College Guides](https://www.collegesref.com/blog?category=college-guides). ## Worked Payback Scenarios: Public vs. Private Nonprofit vs. Out-of-State ### A first-generation student comparing in-state public and private nonprofit options The household figures in this scenario are hypothetical. A student from a family earning $45,000 annually is choosing between an in-state public university and a local private nonprofit college. First, the student gathers the net price and earnings data. For the public option, the student uses the median average net price for public colleges of $10,516 from CollegesRef data. The median earnings ten years after entry for this sector are $49,519. For the private nonprofit option, the student uses the median average net price of $27,122 and median earnings of $69,642. Second, the student calculates the four-year net cost for each school. * Public college: $10,516 multiplied by 4 years. * Private nonprofit college: $27,122 multiplied by 4 years. Third, the student divides the four-year net cost by the median earnings to find the payback period. According to CollegesRef data, public colleges pay back in a median 0.97 years of earnings, while private nonprofit colleges pay back in a median 1.55 years of earnings. * Public college payback: 0.97 years. * Private nonprofit payback: 1.55 years. The student decides to attend the in-state public university. Although the private nonprofit college leads to higher median earnings, the public university allows the student to pay back the cost of the degree in less than one year of post-college work. This choice minimizes the need for student loans, which is a priority for their household. ### A student choosing between in-state public and out-of-state public universities The household figures in this scenario are hypothetical. A student is comparing their local in-state flagship university with an out-of-state public university. First, the student identifies the pricing and earnings metrics. For the in-state public option, the student uses the median in-state tuition of $6,089 and the median average net price of $10,516. For the out-of-state public option, the student uses the median out-of-state tuition of $12,656. The median earnings for both options are assumed to be the public sector median of $49,519. Second, the student calculates the total four-year net cost for both paths. * In-state public college: $10,516 multiplied by 4 years. Third, the student calculates the payback period. * In-state public payback: the four-year net cost divided by $49,519 equals 0.85 years. * Out-of-state public payback: the four-year net cost divided by $49,519 equals 1.38 years. The student chooses the in-state public university. The out-of-state option requires a higher total net cost without offering a corresponding increase in median graduate earnings. Staying in-state keeps the payback period under one year. ### A high-achieving student comparing a public university and a selective private nonprofit The household figures in this scenario are hypothetical. A student with strong academic credentials is admitted to an in-state public university and a selective private nonprofit college that offers generous institutional need-based aid. First, the student looks up the financial figures. The in-state public university has a median average net price of $10,516 and median graduate earnings of $49,519. The selective private nonprofit college has a higher published tuition, but due to the family's income level, the financial aid office offers a net price of $12,000. The median earnings for graduates of this private nonprofit college are $69,642. Second, the student calculates the four-year net cost. * Public university: $10,516 multiplied by 4 years. * Private nonprofit university: $12,000 multiplied by 4 years equals $48,000. Third, the student calculates the payback period. * Public university payback: the four-year net cost divided by $49,519 equals 0.85 years. * Private nonprofit payback: $48,000 divided by $69,642 equals 0.69 years. The student chooses the private nonprofit college. Because of the generous financial aid package, the four-year net cost is nearly identical to the public option, while the higher median graduate earnings reduce the payback period to just 8.3 months of work. You can repeat these calculation steps with your own financial aid offers and target schools using the [CollegesRef College Cost Estimator](https://www.collegesref.com/tools/cost-estimator). ## Frequently asked questions ### What is the average national net price for a four-year college? The national median net price after grants at four-year colleges is $19,835, according to CollegesRef data from the College Scorecard. This figure represents the actual cost families pay after subtracting all federal, state, and institutional scholarships. It provides a more realistic baseline for financial planning than the published sticker price. ### Which college has the fastest degree payback period in the United States? California State University-Los Angeles has the fastest payback period at 0.15 years among colleges with an average net price of at least $2,000 a year. According to data from the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition, this rapid payback is driven by a low average net price of $2,385 and a high median graduate earnings figure of $62,555. ### How much can a dependent undergraduate borrow in federal student loans over four years? A dependent undergraduate can borrow a maximum of $27,000 in federal Direct Loans over four years of study. According to studentaid.gov, the annual limits are capped at $5,500 for the first year, $6,500 for the second year, and $7,500 for the third year and beyond. This total is lower than the $31,000 absolute aggregate limit, which requires additional semesters to reach. ### Are Parent PLUS loans capped for the 2026-27 academic year? Yes, Parent PLUS loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2026, are capped at $20,000 per year and $65,000 in total per dependent student. According to studentaid.gov, this cap represents a major shift from previous years when parents could borrow up to the full cost of attendance. Families must now find alternative funding sources if their college costs exceed this limit. ### What is the maximum Federal Pell Grant amount for 2026-27? The maximum Federal Pell Grant for the 2026-27 award year is $7,395. According to studentaid.gov, this need-based aid does not have to be repaid by the student. The exact amount an individual applicant receives depends on their Student Aid Index, which is calculated using the family financial information provided on the FAFSA. ### Do private colleges always have higher graduation rates than public universities? No, private colleges do not always have higher graduation rates than public universities, despite the sector-wide median graduation rate of 70% for private nonprofits compared to 42% for public colleges. For example, Texas A & M University-College Station, a public institution, has an 85% graduation rate. This is significantly higher than the 42% graduation rate at Southern New Hampshire University, which is a private nonprofit institution. ### How do out-of-state public tuition rates compare to private college costs? The median out-of-state public tuition is $12,656, which is substantially lower than the median private nonprofit tuition of $48,600. According to CollegesRef data, even when adding room and board, public out-of-state sticker prices often remain cheaper than private options. However, private colleges sometimes offer larger institutional merit grants that can bridge this pricing gap. ### Can graduate students still borrow through the Grad PLUS loan program? No, graduate students can no longer borrow through the Grad PLUS loan program if they are new borrowers on or after July 1, 2026. According to studentaid.gov, new graduate borrowers may instead borrow up to $20,500 a year in Direct Unsubsidized Loans, up to a lifetime aggregate limit of $100,000. Professional students have a higher annual limit of $50,000. ## How we put this guide together College figures in this guide come from the federal IPEDS and College Scorecard records CollegesRef imports and checks; the table and chart are CollegesRef calculations from those records. The analysis covers IPEDS and College Scorecard data for 1,442 published U.S. colleges with at least 2,000 students (latest data year 2025). Net price is the average paid by first-time, full-time students who receive grant aid. Federal aid rules and amounts were checked against studentaid.gov and the other official sources below on 2026-11-15. ## Sources - [National Center for Education Statistics, Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS)](https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/) - [U.S. Department of Education, College Scorecard](https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/) - [studentaid.gov: Subsidized Unsubsidized](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized) - [studentaid.gov: Parent](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/plus/parent) - [collegescorecard.ed.gov: Data](https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data/) *Editorial note: CollegesRef publishes research guidance, not individualized financial, legal, or admissions advice. College figures come from federal IPEDS and College Scorecard data imported into CollegesRef. Federal aid amounts can change each award year, so confirm them on studentaid.gov before acting. Figures last checked against CollegesRef data on November 22, 2026.* --- Published by CollegesRef Editorial. Figures checked against U.S. Department of Education data on November 22, 2026. How we create content: https://www.collegesref.com/methodology#how-we-create-content Source: CollegesRef, https://www.collegesref.com/blog/public-vs-private-college-which-pays-for-itself-faster-what-earnings-data-shows. When citing a figure, include the data year stated next to it.