# How CollegesRef sources, defines and compares college data > Where every number comes from and how often it is refreshed, how each figure is defined, how similar-college matches and rankings are calculated, and how our content is made. - Page: https://www.collegesref.com/methodology - Last updated: 2026-11-16 ## Where our data comes from | Source | What we use it for | Release in use | How often it is refreshed | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | College Scorecard (U.S. Department of Education) | College admissions, cost, net price by income, aid, graduation, retention, transfer, debt and earnings; field-of-study earnings and debt. | Latest data, fetched Nov 2026. Each figure is the newest period the Department has published for it, so periods differ by metric: costs, aid and admissions describe a recent academic year; graduation follows students for up to 6 years (8 for outcome measures); earnings are measured 10 years after students first enrolled. | Checked every week: each run re-reads up to 500 colleges whose figures were last checked more than 30 days ago. Income bands, debt, transfer and field-of-study files are reloaded when a new release is published. | | IPEDS directory (NCES) | Institution identity (UNITID), name, location and type. | Latest directory file | Imported when NCES publishes a new directory file, about once a year. | | BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics | National median pay for each career. | May 2025 | Checked every September for a new release. | | BLS Employment Projections | Projected job growth, yearly openings and typical entry-level education. | 2025–2035 | Checked every September for a new release. | | O*NET (U.S. Department of Labor) | Career descriptions, interests, work activities, skills and alternate titles. | O*NET 31.0 | Checked monthly for a new version. | | NCES CIP–SOC crosswalk | Links fields of study to related careers. | CIP 2020 to SOC 2018 | Checked every September. | | Colleges' own published data (Common Data Set, tuition pages) | Latest official data on the profiles of verified colleges: acceptance rate, applicants and admits, SAT/ACT middle 50%, first-year retention, and tuition and fees. Shown beside the federal figure, naming the college's document and its academic year, both read from the data. Rankings, compare tables and data stories keep federal data. Text a college submits through its approved college account is shown separately, labelled as provided by the college. | The newest edition each college publishes; the year is shown on each figure | Checked nightly for the colleges due, and every college at least once a year. A figure goes live only after it passes the checks under "Federal and latest official data"; anything else waits for review. | O*NET 31.0 Database by the U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration (USDOL/ETA). Used under the CC BY 4.0 license. CollegesRef has modified all or some of this information. ## How pages stay current 1. **Federal source:** College Scorecard API and IPEDS files, matched by UNITID. 2. **Import and normalise:** Fields map to one schema; the raw provider payload is stored with each sync for audit. 3. **Checks:** Implausible values are flagged; when a figure changes, editorial text that quotes it is flagged and refreshed or cleared. 4. **Published profile:** Each figure shows its dataset and year; missing measures stay blank. 5. **Matching and guides:** Similar-college lists, rankings and data guides are rebuilt from the published figures. | Page | How it stays current | | --- | --- | | College figures | Re-checked against the College Scorecard on a weekly cycle. Each figure shows its data year. | | Similar colleges | Recomputed on the first of every month, and for a college with no stored list the first time its page is requested. | | Data stories | Recomputed every Monday; a story's update date changes only when its numbers do. | | Best colleges by major | Rebuilt when new College Scorecard field-of-study data is imported. | | Search indexing | Checked daily: pages without enough verified data are kept out of search results until they are complete. | | Career pages | Updated after each O*NET and BLS release. Every career shows its wage year and projection period. | ## How each figure is defined | Figure | Definition | Source | | --- | --- | --- | | Acceptance rate | Applicants offered admission divided by all applicants, for the reported year (Scorecard overall admission rate). | Scorecard | | Yield | Admitted students who enrolled divided by students admitted, computed from the two reported counts. Shown only when both exist. | Derived | | SAT / ACT middle 50% | The 25th and 75th percentile scores of enrolled students who submitted them. | Scorecard | | Tuition | Published in-state and out-of-state tuition and fees for one year: the sticker price before aid. | Scorecard | | Average net price | What first-time, full-time students who received grant aid paid on average after grants and scholarships, including housing, food and books. Public and private colleges report it in separate fields; we use the one that applies. | Scorecard | | Net price by family income | The same average net price for students who received federal aid, split into five family-income bands: $0–30,000, $30,001–48,000, $48,001–75,000, $75,001–110,000 and over $110,000. | Scorecard | | Graduation rate | First-time, full-time students who completed within 150% of normal time: six years for a four-year degree, three for a two-year program. | Scorecard | | Retention rate | First-time, full-time students who returned for a second year. | Scorecard | | Transfer-out rate | First-time, full-time students who transferred to another institution. Shown with the graduation rate, mainly for two-year colleges. | Scorecard | | Median earnings | Median earnings of former students ten years after they first enrolled, counting students who received federal aid. Program pages use earnings one and four years after completing the program. | Scorecard | | Median debt | Median federal loan debt of students who completed, with Scorecard's estimate of the monthly payment. | Scorecard | | Pell grant share | Share of undergraduates receiving a federal Pell grant, a signal of how many students come from lower-income families. | Scorecard | ## Which colleges are included CollegesRef covers U.S. colleges that report to the Department of Education. Every profile follows the rules shown here, and a profile is offered to search engines only when it has enough verified data to be useful. 1. Reports to the U.S. Department of Education and is identified by its IPEDS UNITID. 2. Located in the 50 states or the District of Columbia. 3. Universities, four-year colleges, community colleges and career schools are all covered. 4. Public, private nonprofit and private for-profit colleges are all covered. 5. Published once it has a name, a state and an admission rate or enrollment figure. 6. Offered to search engines only with verified net price, outcome and admissions figures. 7. Colleges reported as closed stay readable but are kept out of search results. 8. A missing figure stays blank. We never estimate a college's data. Today 4,400+ colleges have a published profile, and 3,700+ of them meet the bar for search engines. ### Objective attributes Data alone does not say enough about a college, so profiles also carry objective attributes: NCAA division, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, Tribal colleges, women's colleges, military service academies, religious affiliation and special focus. ### Campus culture Some similarities are not in any federal file, such as which colleges count as the Southern Ivies. These campus-culture groupings are editorial judgments, and they are labelled as editorial, never as federal data. ## How similar colleges are matched Similar-college lists come from fixed rules applied to our data, not from AI. Each list holds up to 10 colleges, and the same inputs always give the same list (matching version legacy-1.2.0). 1. **Same kind of college:** Candidates come only from colleges in the same Carnegie group (for example research universities, or baccalaureate colleges) with the same control: public, private nonprofit or for-profit. 2. **Base points:** Every candidate starts at 1,500 points. 3. **Shared features:** Points are added for each feature both colleges share, such as service academy, HBCU, Jesuit or women's college. The full list of features and points is in the table below. 4. **Location:** A college in the same state adds 100 points; one in a neighbouring state adds 50. 5. **Related names:** Colleges in the same system or with a related name can add points from a fixed rule list. 6. **Editor-confirmed pairs:** A small set of pairs confirmed as true peers receive 5,000 points, which in practice puts them first. 7. **Branch campuses and unpublished colleges:** For a main or standalone campus, branch campuses are left out, and colleges without a published profile are used only when too few others qualify. 8. **Order:** Matches are ordered by points. Colleges tied on points are ordered by profile closeness (below), then distance; the last tie-breaker is the name. ### Shared-feature points | Points | Shared feature | | --- | --- | | +700 | Military Service Academy; Block-Plan College; Mormon-Affiliated College; Strong Disability Services | | +450 | Historically-Black College or University | | +300 | Jesuit College | | +250 | A Member of the Ivy League | | +200 | Historically Leans Conservative (relative to other American colleges); Women's College; Men's College; Lots of Concentration on Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math; Strong Athletic Program | | +100 | A State's Flagship Public University or Similar; A So-Called "Ivy of the South"; A Liberal Arts College Like a "Little Ivy"; Historically Leans Liberal (relative to other American colleges); Has Strong Religious History or Tradition; More "Dry" Social Activities; Has a "Pre-Professional" Feel; Academically-Serious Students; Seventh-Day Adventist College; Catholic College; Presbyterian College | | +50 | Vibrant Social Scene; Quaker College; Big Fraternity/Sorority Scene; Enrolls a High Percentage of International Students | | +25 | Enrolls a Larger Percentage of Jewish Students; Has a Co-Op Program | | +20 | Lutheran College; Methodist College; Baptist College | | +5 | Need-Blind in Admission; Has a POSSE Chapter; Is a QuestBridge Campus | ### Profile closeness | Figure compared | Weight | Scores zero at | | --- | --- | --- | | Graduation rate | 30% | 40 percentage points apart | | Enrollment size | 25% | one campus 8× the other's enrollment | | Acceptance rate | 15% | 50 percentage points apart | | Average net price | 15% | $15,000 a year apart | | Carnegie classification | 10% | 4 Carnegie codes apart | | Public or private | 5% | different control | ### What the match score means - The number next to each match is profile closeness, from 0 to 100. Each dimension scores 1 when the two colleges' figures are equal and falls in a straight line to 0 at the distance in the table; the score is the weighted average times 100. - A figure missing on either side counts as 0.3, below neutral, so colleges with thin data do not float to the top. - Dimensions scoring 0.8 or more are listed as what the colleges share (up to 3); 0.4 or less as differences (up to 2). - There is no letter grade. Closeness measures how alike two colleges' published figures are. It does not rate either college's quality or predict your fit or admission chances. - Because the order also counts shared features and location, a college lower in the list can have higher closeness than one above it. - A "colleges like" page is offered to search engines only when at least 4 of its matches are strong: closeness of 50 or more and at least 2 shared figures. ## How rankings and data stories are built | Factor | Weight | | --- | --- | | Graduates' median earnings | 40% | | Average net price (lower is better) | 25% | | Federal debt compared with earnings (lower is better) | 20% | | College graduation rate | 15% | - Best colleges by major ranks bachelor's programs at public and private nonprofit colleges. Each factor is a percentile among the ranked colleges, and the value score is their weighted average; when a college has no debt figure, that weight is shared among the other three. Earnings are measured 4 years after graduation. - A college is ranked only when its program had at least 20 graduates in the latest award year with reported earnings, and it has a published net price and graduation rate. A few small fields use a lower minimum, stated on their page. - A major is published only when at least 50 colleges qualify; 20 majors meet that bar today. State lists appear only where at least five ranked colleges are in the state, and keep the national ranks. - Data stories compare four-year public and private nonprofit colleges with at least 500 undergraduates, and report a state only when it has at least 5 qualifying colleges. Each story states any further thresholds and exclusions on its page and in its CSV. - Every ranking and story uses the same federal figures and definitions for every college, so colleges are compared on the same basis. A missing figure leaves the college out; it is never filled in. - No college can pay to be ranked, to rank higher, or to change a figure. ## Verified data, editorial view and AI interpretation - **Verified College Data:** Federal figures from IPEDS and the College Scorecard, each with its dataset and year. We do not edit them by hand. - **CollegesRef Editorial View:** Commentary and attributes from CollegesRef Editorial, labelled as editorial. It is opinion grounded in the data, not a federal record. - **Personalized AI Interpretation:** Advisor answers and report explanations generated for one visitor. Labelled as AI, built only from figures already on CollegesRef, and never a fact about a college. - **Sponsored:** Any paid placement is labelled as sponsored and never changes data, matching, rankings or editorial views. ## How we create content CollegesRef Editorial publishes the guides on this site. Most are drafted with AI tools from figures pulled out of our verified federal data, and code checks those figures before a guide can be published. AI also writes labelled explanations in tools and reports. These are the rules, as enforced in code. - AI drafts guides and explanations; it never supplies the numbers. Every dollar amount, percentage and large count in a generated guide must match a figure in the evidence pulled from our verified data or our federal-aid reference table, or it is flagged as unverified. - A quality gate checks each draft: a direct-answer opening, key takeaways, a data table, an FAQ, a sources section with at least one official source, an editorial disclaimer, little overlap with guides already published, and zero unverified figures. - Publishing is automated. A draft goes live only when it scores at least 85 on the gate with no unverified figures and no banned phrases; any other draft is held back. - Guides are published under CollegesRef Editorial. Each ends with the date its figures were last checked against U.S. Department of Education data and links back to this section. We do not attribute guides to named authors, and the rules forbid invented people, quotes, anecdotes and claims of first-hand experience. - When a federal figure changes, editorial text that quotes it is flagged and refreshed or cleared. - AI advisor answers are checked against the evidence they were given: an answer stating a dollar amount, percentage or large number that matches nothing in that evidence is rejected. - Scholarship listings found on official websites are read by AI, then checked by code: a program name, amount or date that does not appear on the official page is dropped, and only listings from official sources with a working link and a dated deadline go live automatically. ## What we don't do - **No paid rankings:** No college or partner can pay to appear in, or move up, a ranking, a similar-college list, a match score or a scholarship result. - **Sponsored placements would be labelled:** None run today. If partner plans for colleges launch, a college could show one card labelled "Sponsored" on some pages, apart from rankings and matches and never reordering them. - **Ads are labelled:** No display ads run today. If they are added, they will be labelled "Advertisement" and kept to guides and data stories, never on college profiles, tools or checkout. - **No invented reviews:** We do not write reviews or testimonials and attribute them to students or families. Reviews of our paid reports come only from verified buyers and are published whatever their rating. - **No invented people:** We do not invent authors, experts or staff credentials. Guides are published by CollegesRef Editorial. - **No edited federal figures:** We never change a federal figure by hand or estimate a missing one. ## Corrections policy If a figure or statement on CollegesRef is wrong, tell us. Federal figures are checked against the source release; editorial text is corrected or removed. Email info@collegesref.com with: - The page URL - The figure or sentence you think is wrong - A source for the correct value, if you have one (for example the college's Common Data Set or IPEDS page) We cannot change a federal figure that matches the published federal data, but we will note a known reporting error next to it. ## Limitations - Federal data lags: the most recent Scorecard and IPEDS figures describe students who enrolled one to several years ago. - Figures are reported by the colleges themselves to the Department of Education. - Small groups are suppressed for privacy, so some measures are blank for small colleges. - Average net price is an average across aided students; your own price depends on your family's finances. Use each college's net price calculator. - Median earnings cover only students who received federal aid and depend heavily on field of study. - Graduation rates count first-time, full-time students; transfer and part-time students are not included. - Similar-college lists measure institutional similarity, not fit for you. - **UNITID:** The permanent IPEDS identifier for an institution. - **Carnegie classification:** A standard grouping of colleges by type and research activity, such as R1 doctoral universities or baccalaureate colleges. - **First-time, full-time:** Students starting college for the first time and enrolled full time, the group most federal outcome measures follow. - **Latest data:** The newest period a federal source has published for a figure. Periods differ by metric; this page lists them for each source. ## Changelog - **2026-11-16:** Latest official data: for verified colleges, profiles now also show figures from the college's own Common Data Set or tuition page (acceptance rate, test scores, retention, tuition and fees), labelled with the document and the academic year read from the data, beside the federal figure. Federal data remains the basis for rankings, compare tables and data stories. - **2026-11-16:** Page rewritten as a reference. Added source release years, refresh schedule, rankings and data stories, what we don't do, and this changelog. Coverage rules corrected to match today's catalog, which includes community colleges, career schools and for-profit colleges. Matching rules restated in full, with weights and points read from the live configuration. - **2026-11-15:** "How we create content" added: AI drafting, automated figure checks and the editorial line at the end of each guide. - **2026-11-07:** Similar colleges version legacy-1.2.0: colleges without a published profile only fill out short lists; neighbouring-state rules for two states corrected. - **2026-11-06:** Career data sources (BLS, O*NET, CIP–SOC crosswalk) added; best colleges by major introduced; unverifiable claims removed from this page. - **2026-11-04:** Methodology published: data sources, figure definitions and similar-college rules. ## Frequently asked questions ### Where does CollegesRef get its college data? From the U.S. Department of Education: the College Scorecard and IPEDS. Each college is identified by its IPEDS UNITID, and every figure shows its dataset and year. For verified colleges, profiles also show the latest official data from the college's own Common Data Set or tuition page, labelled with its document and year, beside the federal figure. Career data comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and O*NET. ### How often is the data updated? College figures are re-checked against the College Scorecard on a weekly cycle, similar-college lists are recomputed monthly and data stories weekly. Federal agencies publish new data about once a year, and every figure shows its data year. ### What does the match score mean? It is profile closeness out of 100: how alike two colleges' graduation rate, size, acceptance rate, net price, Carnegie class and control are. It does not rate quality or predict your admission chances, and there is no letter grade. ### Is the acceptance rate the same as my chance of getting in? No. It is the share of all applicants admitted in the reported year. Your chances depend on your record, the program and how selective the college is for applicants like you. ### Does AI decide which colleges are similar or how they rank? No. Similar-college lists and rankings come from fixed rules on verified figures. AI drafts guides and labelled explanations, and code checks every figure it uses. ### Can a college pay to rank higher? No. Payment cannot change a ranking, a match, a score or a figure. A sponsored card is labelled and kept apart from ranked lists. ### Why is a figure missing for some colleges? The college did not report it, or the group was too small and the Department of Education suppressed it for privacy. We leave it blank rather than estimate. ### Does CollegesRef crawl other websites? Only official sources, for two purposes. To find scholarships, on a fixed list: federal and state aid agencies, college websites, foundations and associations that run their own awards. To read a college's own Common Data Set and tuition page, on that college's website and the public files it links to; a page that asks for a CAPTCHA or a login is left alone. Our crawler identifies itself as CollegesRefBot, follows robots.txt and Crawl-delay, fetches at most one page every 5 seconds per site, and never reads scholarship search sites or application portals. When a college page refuses that request, we may try it once more in a standard browser, only where robots.txt allows the page. To ask us to stop, block CollegesRefBot in robots.txt or email info@collegesref.com. ### How do I report an error? Email info@collegesref.com with the page URL, the figure, and a source for the correct value if you have one. --- Source: CollegesRef, https://www.collegesref.com/methodology.