
Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science
Paul Smiths, NY
Profile closeness95/100
Admit rate77%
- 579 students
- Private nonprofit
- Rural: Distant
- Graduation rate 46%, close to 48%
- Enrollment 579 students, close to 708
2,500+ community & trade schoolsNew: 2,500+ community colleges and trade schools added. By stateExplore by state
Similar colleges
Closest matches: Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science, Hilbert College and St. Thomas Aquinas College. All 10 are ranked by shared features and how close their published figures are.
Data verified Nov 2026 · CollegesRef 2026–27 edition
The colleges most similar to Elmira College are Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science (graduation rate 46%, close to 48%); Hilbert College (enrollment 921 students, close to 708); and St. Thomas Aquinas College (average net price $21,253, close to $23,178). Elmira College admits 77% of applicants and has an average net price of $23,178 a year; 6 of its 10 alternatives cost less and 5 admit a larger share of applicants, in the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition.
These matches are closest to Elmira College on graduation rate and acceptance rate. The score is profile closeness out of 100; the order also counts shared features and location. How matches are scored
| College | State | Acceptance rate | Net price | Graduation rate | Median earnings | Match score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elmira College | NY | 77% | $23,178 | 48.4% | $63,320 | This college |
| Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science | NY | 76.5% | $23,753 | 46.5% | $52,012 | 95/100 |
| Hilbert College | NY | 97.2% | $20,955 | 50% | $55,931 | 87/100 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas College | NY | 93.1% | $21,253 | 53.3% | $65,466 | 81/100 |
| St. Francis College | NY | 85% | $17,300 | 51.4% | $66,961 | 79/100 |
| Alfred University | NY | 73.8% | $22,325 | 45.6% | $57,978 | 78/100 |
| Roberts Wesleyan College | NY | 70.6% | $23,239 | 39% | $64,154 | 75/100 |
| College of Mount Saint Vincent | NY | 85.1% | $19,758 | 52.4% | $70,998 | 75/100 |
| Keuka College | NY | 68.1% | $35,459 | 48.8% | $62,019 | 73/100 |
| Hartwick College | NY | 69.6% | $36,296 | 53.2% | $66,557 | 73/100 |
| Villa Maria College | NY | 86.6% | $12,863 | 32.3% | $38,993 | 73/100 |
Net price is the average yearly cost after grants; graduation rate is within six years; earnings are ten years after entry. Match score is profile closeness out of 100. “Not reported” means the college sent no figure to the U.S. Department of Education.
Ranked by similarity. Each card lists what the college shares with Elmira College and where it differs.

Paul Smiths, NY
Profile closeness95/100
Admit rate77%

Hamburg, NY
Profile closeness87/100
Admit rate97%

Sparkill, NY
Profile closeness81/100
Admit rate93%

Brooklyn Heights, NY
Profile closeness79/100
Admit rate85%

Alfred, NY
Profile closeness78/100
Admit rate74%

Rochester, NY
Profile closeness75/100
Admit rate71%

Bronx, NY
Profile closeness75/100
Admit rate85%

Keuka Park, NY
Profile closeness73/100
Admit rate68%

Oneonta, NY
Profile closeness73/100
Admit rate70%

Buffalo, NY
Profile closeness73/100
Admit rate87%
The closest matches to Elmira College are Paul Smiths College of Arts and Science, Hilbert College, St. Thomas Aquinas College, St. Francis College, and Alfred University. CollegesRef ranks them on admissions, cost, graduation rate, size, and campus profile using IPEDS and College Scorecard data.
Elmira College admitted 77% of applicants in the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition, so it is not very selective: it admits most applicants. 5 of its 10 closest alternatives admit a larger share of applicants.
6 of the 10 closest alternatives have a lower average net price than Elmira College ($23,178 a year), including Villa Maria College ($12,863), St. Francis College ($17,300), and College of Mount Saint Vincent ($19,758). Net price is what first-time, full-time students paid after grants; your own price depends on family income.
Matches and their reasons come from CollegesRef matching on these figures. How we match colleges
Featured colleges
Acceptance rates, tuition and verified admissions data. Data verified Nov 2026 · CollegesRef 2026–27 edition.
Bars: admit rate on a 0–100% scale; tuition relative to the highest tuition shown here.