
Calvin University
Grand Rapids, MI
Profile closeness54/100
Admit rate71%
- 3,193 students
- Private nonprofit
- City: Midsize
- Same control type (private nonprofit)
- Differs: Acceptance rate 71%, far less selective than 21%
2,500+ community & trade schoolsNew: 2,500+ community colleges and trade schools added. By stateExplore by state
Similar colleges
Closest matches: Calvin University, University of Notre Dame-South Bend IN and Wheaton College-Illinois. All 10 are ranked by shared features and how close their published figures are, plus 10 curated AI picks.
Data verified Nov 2026 · CollegesRef 2026–27 edition
The colleges most similar to Hillsdale College are Calvin University (same control type (private nonprofit)); University of Notre Dame-South Bend IN (graduation rate 95%, close to 89%); and Wheaton College-Illinois (enrollment 2,341 students, close to 1,573). Hillsdale College admits 21% of applicants; 8 admit a larger share of applicants, in the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition.
The score is profile closeness out of 100; the order also counts shared features and location. How matches are scored
| College | State | Acceptance rate | Net price | Graduation rate | Median earnings | Match score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hillsdale College | MI | 20.7% | Not reported | 89.1% | Not reported | This college |
| Calvin University | MI | 70.9% | $21,122 | 76.8% | $60,411 | 54/100 |
| University of Notre Dame-South Bend IN | IN | 11.3% | $25,339 | 95.4% | $113,124 | 51/100 |
| Wheaton College-Illinois | IL | 86% | Not reported | 88% | Not reported | 69/100 |
| College of the Ozarks | MO | 12% | $13,114 | 63.2% | $47,246 | 64/100 |
| Grove City College | PA | 72.3% | Not reported | 80.8% | Not reported | 62/100 |
| Gordon College | MA | 69.2% | $25,227 | 70.6% | $59,863 | 59/100 |
| Thomas Aquinas College | CA | 83.1% | $30,972 | 83.5% | $59,595 | 58/100 |
| Berry College | GA | 64% | $21,964 | 71.2% | $57,984 | 56/100 |
| University of Dallas | TX | 53.4% | $68,064 | 66.5% | $64,930 | 54/100 |
| Baylor University | TX | 51.3% | $44,441 | 82.3% | $72,408 | 40/100 |
Net price is the average yearly cost after grants; graduation rate is within six years; earnings are ten years after entry. Match score is profile closeness out of 100. “Not reported” means the college sent no figure to the U.S. Department of Education.
Algorithm-ranked matches similar to Hillsdale College

Grand Rapids, MI
Profile closeness54/100
Admit rate71%

Notre Dame, IN
Profile closeness51/100
Admit rate11%

Wheaton, IL
Profile closeness69/100
Admit rate86%

Point Lookout, MO
Profile closeness64/100
Admit rate12%

Grove City, PA
Profile closeness62/100
Admit rate72%

Wenham, MA
Profile closeness59/100
Admit rate69%

Santa Paula, CA
Profile closeness58/100
Admit rate83%

Mount Berry, GA
Profile closeness56/100
Admit rate64%

Irving, TX
Profile closeness54/100
Admit rate53%

Waco, TX
Profile closeness40/100
Admit rate51%
Editor-curated list for Hillsdale College

Lynchburg, VA
Profile closeness—
Admit rate99%

Claremont, CA
Profile closeness—
Admit rate10%

Grove City, PA
Profile closeness62/100
Admit rate72%

Malibu, CA
Profile closeness—
Admit rate63%

Point Lookout, MO
Profile closeness64/100
Admit rate12%

Purcellville, VA
Profile closeness—
Admit rate77%

New York, NY
Profile closeness—
Admit rate44%
Merrimack, NH
Profile closeness—
Admit rate—

Steubenville, OH
Profile closeness—
Admit rate58%

Provo, UT
Profile closeness—
Admit rate68%
The closest matches to Hillsdale College are Calvin University, University of Notre Dame-South Bend IN, Wheaton College-Illinois, College of the Ozarks, and Grove City College. CollegesRef ranks them on admissions, cost, graduation rate, size, and campus profile using IPEDS and College Scorecard data.
Hillsdale College admitted 21% of applicants in the CollegesRef 2026–27 edition, so it is highly selective. 8 of its 10 closest alternatives admit a larger share of applicants.
Matches and their reasons come from CollegesRef matching on these figures. How we match colleges
Featured colleges
Acceptance rates, tuition and verified admissions data. Data verified Nov 2026 · CollegesRef 2026–27 edition.
Bars: admit rate on a 0–100% scale; tuition relative to the highest tuition shown here.